Support our educational content for free when you purchase through links on our site. Learn more
15 Most Responsible Car Brands by Incident Data (2026) š
Thereās no single brand that can claim the title of most responsible car brand across every measure. In LendingTreeās 2026 study, Chrysler had the lowest overall incident rate among the 30 makes analyzed, while Mercury had the lowest reported accident rateātwo different answers because āincidentsā include more than crashes.
That distinction matters when a ranking starts looking like a verdict on every driver behind a particular badge. Weāve seen how quickly āmore reported incidentsā turns into āthat brandās drivers are reckless,ā even though study samples, mileage, vehicle mix, and whether a crash was at fault all shape the numbers.
We compare 15 major brands, explain what the data canāand canātāprove, and show how to pair incident statistics with crash-test ratings, recalls, and insurance quotes. The best choice isnāt simply the brand with the lowest number; itās a specific vehicle that fits your driving needs and checks out on the evidence.
Key Takeaways
- Chrysler had the lowest overall incident rate in LendingTreeās 2026 study: 25.5 incidents per 1,000 drivers in its dataset.
- Mercury had the lowest reported accident rate in the supplied results, while Ram had the highest.
- BMW, Ram, and Tesla had the highest overall incident rates in that studyābut these are sample-specific comparisons, not judgments about every owner.
- Incident rates arenāt the same as at-fault crashes or crash-test safety. Check the measure, sample, and denominator before trusting a ranking.
- Compare the specific model and year, including independent safety ratings, recalls, available driver-assistance features, and insurance quotes.
- Your driving habits matter more than a badge: avoid speeding, distraction, and impaired driving, and treat assistance features as backupānot a chauffeur.
Table of Contents
- ā”ļø Quick Tips and Facts
- š What āMost Responsible Car Brandsā Means in Driver Incident Data
- Driver responsibility versus crash involvement
- What counts as a driver incident?
- š How Brand Rankings Are Built
- Incidents per driver, vehicle, or mile
- Insurance claims, citations, crashes, and fatalities
- Why different studies produce different rankings
- š What the Data Canāand CanātāTell You
- Sample size, reporting bias, and data limitations
- Driver demographics, vehicle age, and annual mileage
- Brand reputation versus individual driving behavior
- š 15 Car Brands Compared by Driver Incident Trends
- 1. Subaru driver incident trends
- 2. Volvo driver incident trends
- 3. Honda driver incident trends
- 4. Toyota driver incident trends
- 5. Mazda driver incident trends
- 6. Hyundai driver incident trends
- 7. Kia driver incident trends
- 8. Ford driver incident trends
- 9. Chevrolet driver incident trends
- 10. Nissan driver incident trends
- 11. Volkswagen driver incident trends
- 12. BMW driver incident trends
- 13. Mercedes-Benz driver incident trends
- 14. Dodge driver incident trends
- 15. Tesla driver incident trends
- š Brand-by-Brand Incident Data Comparison
- How to read the comparison table
- Why rankings vary by incident measure
- š¦ Which Brands Show Lower-Risk Driving Patterns?
- Brands associated with fewer reported incidents
- Brands associated with higher-risk incident patterns
- Why āresponsibleā doesnāt mean ācrash-proofā
- š”ļø How Vehicle Safety Features Affect Incident Outcomes
- Automatic emergency braking and forward collision warning
- Lane-keeping assistance and blind-spot monitoring
- Driver-assistance systems: benefits and limitations
- š§ Brand, Model, or Driver: What Matters Most?
- Why one model can differ from its brand average
- Vehicle size, performance, and visibility
- How driving habits shape crash risk
- ā How to Choose a Safer Car and Drive More Responsibly
- Check crash-test ratings and recalls
- Compare insurance loss and claim data
- Practical habits that reduce incident risk
- ā Frequently Asked Questions
- Which car brand has the most responsible drivers?
- Which car brands have the most accidents per driver?
- Are luxury-car drivers involved in more crashes?
- Are popular car brands safer because they have more data?
- Do safety features make drivers more responsible?
- Can driver incident rankings predict my insurance costs?
- Where can I find reliable car-crash and vehicle-safety data?
- Conclusion
- Recommended Links
- Reference Links
Table of Contents
- ā”ļø Quick Tips and Facts
- š What āMost Responsible Car Brandsā Means in Driver Incident Data
- Driver responsibility versus crash involvement
- What counts as a driver incident?
- š How Brand Rankings Are Built
- Incidents per driver, vehicle, or mile
- Insurance claims, citations, crashes, and fatalities
- Why different studies produce different rankings
- š What the Data Canāand CanātāTell You
- Sample size, reporting bias, and data limitations
- Driver demographics, vehicle age, and annual mileage
- Brand reputation versus individual driving behavior
- š 15 Car Brands Compared by Driver Incident Trends
- 1. Subaru driver incident trends
- 2. Volvo driver incident trends
- 3. Honda driver incident trends
- 4. Toyota driver incident trends
- 5. Mazda driver incident trends
- 6. Hyundai driver incident trends
- 7. Kia driver incident trends
- 8. Ford driver incident trends
- 9. Chevrolet driver incident trends
- 10. Nissan driver incident trends
- 11. Volkswagen driver incident trends
- 12. BMW driver incident trends
- 13. Mercedes-Benz driver incident trends
- 14. Dodge driver incident trends
- 15. Tesla driver incident trends
- š Brand-by-Brand Incident Data Comparison
- How to read the comparison table
- Why rankings vary by incident measure
- š¦ Which Brands Show Lower-Risk Driving Patterns?
- Brands associated with fewer reported incidents
- Brands associated with higher-risk incident patterns
- Why āresponsibleā doesnāt mean ācrash-proofā
- š”ļø How Vehicle Safety Features Affect Incident Outcomes
- Automatic emergency braking and forward collision warning
- Lane-keeping assistance and blind-spot monitoring
- Driver-assistance systems: benefits and limitations
- š§ Brand, Model, or Driver: What Matters Most?
- Why one model can differ from its brand average
- Vehicle size, performance, and visibility
- How driving habits shape crash risk
- ā How to Choose a Safer Car and Drive More Responsibly
- Check crash-test ratings and recalls
- Compare insurance loss and claim data
- Practical habits that reduce incident risk
- ā Frequently Asked Questions
- Which car brand has the most responsible drivers?
- Which car brands have the most accidents per driver?
- Are luxury-car drivers involved in more crashes?
- Are popular car brands safer because they have more data?
- Do safety features make drivers more responsible?
- Can driver incident rankings predict my insurance costs?
- Where can I find reliable car-crash and vehicle-safety data?
- Conclusion
- Recommended Links
- Reference Links
ā”ļø Quick Tips and Facts
If youāre comparing vehicles for a cleaner driving record and potentially more manageable insurance, start with our guide to 15 Best Cars for Low Insurance and Clean Driving Records š. Then keep these data-savy takeaways in mind:
- āMost responsible brandā depends on what gets counted. A study that combines crashes, DUIs, speeding incidents, and citations answers a different question from a crash-only dataset.
- In its 2026 brand incident analysis, LendingTree reported 25.5 incidents per 1,000 drivers for Chrysler, the lowest among the 30 makes analyzed. BMW ranked highest at 44.9, followed closely by Ram at 44.7 and Tesla at 42.8.
- The same LendingTree study found the highest accident rates for Ram (23.9), Subaru (23.2), Tesla (23.1), and BMW (22.9) per 1,000 drivers. Those are rates in the studyās insurance-inquiry dataset, not universal crash probabilities for every owner.
- Raw reports to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) are not brand safety rankings. More vehicles, more miles, greater reporting, and different system exposure can mean more reports.
- A vehicle brand does not determine your driving behavior. Speed, impairment, distraction, seat-belt use, road conditions, vehicle maintenance, and mileage all matter.
- Brand-wide incident statistics do not directly set your lease payment. Your lease quote and insurance premium depend on different factors, including the specific vehicle, your driving and claims history, location, coverage, and insurer.
- ā Use brand statistics as a screening clue, then check the specific modelās crash tests, recalls, insurance-loss information, and safety equipment.
- ā Donāt assume a low incident rate makes a model crash-proofāor that every driver of a high-rate brand is reckless.
| Quick question | Useful starting point | What to remember |
|---|---|---|
| Which brand had the lowest overall rate in LendingTreeās 2026 study? | Chrysler, 25.5 per 1,000 drivers | It is a study-specific result, not a guarantee for a given model or driver. |
| Which brands had the highest overall rates? | BMW, Ram, and Tesla | Incident totals combine several kinds of events, not just crashes. |
| Which brands had the highest accident rates in that analysis? | Ram, Subaru, Tesla, and BMW | These are per-driver rates in LendingTreeās dataset, not per-mile rates. |
| Do incident rankings prove a brand caused crashes? | No | They describe observed records in a particular sample; they donāt establish fault. |
One wrinkle drives nearly every disagreement between brand rankings: the denominator. Are we counting incidents per driver, per registered vehicle, or per mile? Weāll unpack that before trusting any leaderboard.
š What āMost Responsible Car Brandsā Means in Driver Incident Data
The phrase sounds like it should yield one tidy podium: gold, silver, bronze, and a little trophy shaped like a well-used turn signal. In reality, a brandās āresponsibilityā ranking depends on how researchers define an incident, which drivers are included, and how they adjust for exposure.
A useful starting point is to separate driver behavior, vehicle safety, and crash outcomes. These overlap, but theyāre not interchangeable. A car may have excellent crash protection while its owners appear frequently in speeding records. Another brand might show fewer insurance-reported incidents because its owners drive fewer miles, because claims are less likely to be filed, or because the sample differs.
Driver responsibility versus crash involvement
A crash report or insurance claim doesnāt automatically mean a driver was at fault. A vehicle can be struck while parked; a driver can be involved in a multi-vehicle collision without causing it; and a citation may be unrelated to a crash.
Likewise, a brandās crash-involvement rate does not tell us by itself whether the vehicle was unsafe. To assess vehicle safety, we also need crash-test results and crashworthiness research from sources such as the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) and the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA).
We find it helpful to ask three separate questions:
- How often do sampled drivers have recorded incidents?
- How often are vehicles involved in crashes, after adjusting for exposure?
- How well do vehicles protect occupants and other road users when a crash happens?
Those questions can lead to different brand lists, and none should be mistaken for a universal moral score for owners.
What counts as a driver incident?
In LendingTreeās 2026 study, āincidentsā combine accidents, DUIs, speeding incidents, and general citations. The study analyzed tens of millions of QuoteWizard insurance inquiries from January 1 through December 16, 2025, and included the 30 makes with the most inquiries. Its rates are reported per 1,000 drivers.
A NHTSA automated-driving report is a different animal. It concerns reported crashes involving vehicles operating with certain advanced driver-assistance systems (ADAS) or automated driving systems (ADS). It does not count every crash involving that brand, and it does not mean all reported vehicles were driverless.
| Dataset or measure | What it may include | What it does not establish on its own |
|---|---|---|
| Insurance-inquiry incident rate | Accidents, DUI, speeding, and citations in the studyās defined dataset | A national per-mile crash rate or legal fault |
| Police crash records | Crashes reported to law enforcement, with available circumstances and severity | Every unreported crash or the full insurance picture |
| Insurance claims | Claims made under relevant coverages and insurer records | All incidents, all carriers, or driver responsibility in every case |
| NHTSA ADAS/ADS crash reports | Certain reported crashes involving covered automation or assistance systems | All crashes for a brand, system failure, or proof that a car drove autonomously |
| Crash-test ratings | Performance in specified test procedures | How often a particular owner will crash |
Bottom line: Before asking which brand is āmost responsible,ā decide whether you mean responsible driving behavior, fewer recorded incidents, fewer crashes per mile, or better crash protection. They are different scoreboards.
š How Brand Rankings Are Built
Brand rankings are only as meaningful as the inputs underneath them. Our team looks for the studyās time period, sample, incident definitions, rate denominator, and any attempt to account for exposure. If those details are missing, treat the ranking like a weather forecast from someone who forgot to check the sky.
Incidents per driver, vehicle, or mile
A per-driver rate counts incidents relative to the drivers in a dataset. A per-vehicle rate compares incidents with registered or insured vehicles. A per-mile rate adjusts for how much vehicles are actually driven.
Those denominators can change the result. A brand whose owners drive longer distances might rack up more crashes simply because they spend more time on the road. A per-mile measure can help with that comparison, but reliable mileage data by make and model is not always available or measured consistently.
When reading a ranking, look for language like:
- Per 1,000 drivers: compares incident records with a driver sample.
- Per registered vehicle: compares with vehicle counts, but may not capture how much each vehicle is driven.
- Per million miles: adjusts more directly for driving exposure, if the mileage data is sound.
- Raw report totals: counts reports, but does not normalize for fleet size or use.
For its brand study, LendingTree reports rates per 1,000 drivers in its insurance-inquiry dataset. That is useful for comparing makes within the study, but it is not a per-mile measure or a census of every driver in the country.
Insurance claims, citations, crashes, and fatalities
Combining incident types can produce a broad view of recorded driving history, but it can also hide important differences. A speeding incident is not the same kind of outcome as a fatal crash. DUI records, citations, and at-fault insurance claims also have different reporting and legal processes.
We recommend checking both the overall incident rate and its components:
| Measure | What it helps illuminate | Key caution |
|---|---|---|
| Accident rate | Frequency of accident records in the study | May not distinguish fault or severity unless specified |
| DUI rate | Recorded impaired-driving incidents | Legal and reporting definitions can vary |
| Speeding rate | Recorded speeding incidents | Enforcement and citation reporting differ by place |
| General citation rate | Other recorded traffic violations | The category may include a wide range offenses |
| Injury or fatality data | Severity of reported crash outcomes | Small counts and incomplete reporting can complicate comparisons |
LendingTreeās 2026 analysis reported BMW with the highest DUI rate, at 4.8 per 1,000 drivers, while Chrysler and Volvo were lowest at 0.9. For speeding, Infiniti led at 3.3, while several makesāincluding Volkswagen, Mercury, Ram, and Teslaāwere reported at 3.2. These are individual components of a broader study, and they shouldnāt be confused with crash-fatality rankings.
Why different studies produce different rankings
The LendingTree 2026 report puts BMW first for overall incidents among the makes it analyzed. An earlier QuoteWizard/LendingTree analysis summarized by AutoBody News looked at a different period and found Ram highest overall, followed by Tesla and Subaru. Those rankings conflict because the study windows, sample, and observed incident mix differānot necessarily because one analysis is fabricated.
Separate automated-driving reports have another scope altogether. A Craft Law Firm analysis of NHTSA-reported ADS and ADAS incidents reports Tesla with the largest combined number of reports in its table, but warns that totals are not adjusted for how many vehicles each company operates. That makes it a poor tool for declaring which ordinary consumer brand has the worst drivers.
| Why rankings may differ | How it changes the result |
|---|---|
| Different study dates | More recent records can capture changing vehicle fleets or driver behavior. |
| Different driver samples | Insurance quote customers are not the same as all licensed drivers. |
| Different incident definitions | A broad score including citations may differ from a crash-only ranking. |
| Different denominators | Per driver, vehicle, or mile can reorder brands. |
| Different brand mix | A report may include discontinued marques or only high-volume makes. |
| Different system scope | ADAS/ADS reports are not general crash data for all vehicles. |
What should you trust? Trust the study for what it actually measures, then avoid stretching its result beyond that. Weāll use the LendingTree dataset for the comparable per-driver figures below and treat other sources as contextānot as interchangeable scoreboards.
š What the Data Canāand CanātāTell You
Incident data can reveal patterns worth investigating. It canāt diagnose the reason for those patterns on its own. That distinction matters when a brandās reputation starts to run faster than the evidence.
Sample size, reporting bias, and data limitations
LendingTree says its 2026 study analyzed tens of millions of insurance inquiries, but it used the 30 makes with the most inquiries, not every car brand or every U.S. driver. Its large dataset supports meaningful within-sample comparisons, yet the sample is still shaped by who requested a quote, what information was available, and which incidents were represented.
NHTSA automation-related reports have a different limitation. The Craft analysis notes that its reported company totals are not adjusted for fleet size or miles driven. A company operating many vehicles, or one whose vehicles are under more public scrutiny, could accumulate more raw reports without having a higher rate per vehicle or mile.
Keep these guardrails handy:
- Correlation is not causation. Brand and incident records may move together without the brand causing the behavior.
- A reported incident is not automatically an at-fault incident.
- A raw total is not a rate. Always look for an appropriate denominator.
- A rate in an insurance inquiry sample is not necessarily nationally representative.
- Missing data can distort apparent differences. Not every crash, citation, or claim enters every dataset.
Driver demographics, vehicle age, and annual mileage
Drivers do not choose cars randomly. Vehicle type, age, price point, performance, household needs, and location all influence what people buy or lease. Those factors can also be associated with how muchāand whereāpeople drive.
For example, a pickup used for long-distance work may accumulate more road exposure than a second household car used for short errands. A performance model may attract drivers who enjoy brisk acceleration. A brandās typical buyer may also differ in age or geography. Those are plausible explanations to investigate, not proof that a particular group causes the brandās ranking.
LendingTree expert Rob Bhatt suggested in the report that performance models may play a role in higher recorded rates for BMW and Tesla, while some Ram ownership patterns could contribute to risk differences. That is an expert interpretation of possible drivers, not a causal finding established by the dataset.
Brand reputation versus individual driving behavior
A brand average does not know whether you use a seat belt, leave room to brake, put your phone away, or drive sober. It also doesnāt know whether you commute across a city every day or roll the car out for weekend errands.
One finding from an automotive privacy report discussed in the supplied video summary deserves a separate look: the summary says 19 of 25 popular brands sell driver data, 50% acknowledge sharing information, and 84% of car companies admit to selling data. Those numbers concern privacy practices, not driver-incident rates. Data collection may include details such as speed or braking, and the summary raises the possibility of sharing with third parties, including insurers. Check the original report, the vehicle privacy notice, and your insurerās telematics terms before opting in; the figures should not be treated as proof that every brand shares every data point with every insurer.
For broader lease research, our Car Lease Basics and Credit Score and Car Leasing guides can help you separate vehicle choice from lease qualification.
š 15 Car Brands Compared by Driver Incident Trends
The figures below come from LendingTreeās 2026 brand study. Rates are per 1,000 drivers in the studyās dataset, not per mile and not a prediction of what any individual owner will do. Weāve included both the overall incident leaders and lower-rate comparison points to make the differences easier to see.
| Brand | Overall incidents per 1,000 drivers | Study context |
|---|---|---|
| BMW | 44.9 | Highest overall in the 30-brand analysis; also highest DUI rate |
| Ram | 44.7 | Near-highest overall; highest reported accident rate |
| Tesla | 42.8 | Third-highest overall; high reported accident rate |
| Subaru | Not specified in the supplied summary | Accident rate: 23.2 |
| Chrysler | 25.5 | Lowest overall in the 2026 analysis |
| Cadillac | 27.0 | Second-lowest overall |
| Mercury | 27.9 | Third-lowest overall; lowest reported accident rate |
| Volvo | Not specified in the supplied summary | DUI rate: 0.9; overall rate not supplied |
| Infiniti | Not specified in the supplied summary | Highest speeding rate: 3.3 |
| Volkswagen | Not specified in the supplied summary | Speeding rate: 3.2 |
| Mazda | Not specified in the supplied summary | DUI rate: 1.0 |
| Nissan | Not specified in the supplied summary | DUI rate: 1.0 |
| Lexus | Not specified in the supplied summary | DUI rate: 1.0 |
| Buick | Not specified in the supplied summary | Third-highest reported DUI rate: 1.7 |
| Pontiac | Not specified in the supplied summary | Accident rate: 13.3; overall rate not supplied |
Important: āNot specifiedā means the supplied report summary does not provide that brandās overall figure. We wonāt invent a number to make the table look complete. The full report may provide additional brand-level details.
1. Subaru driver incident trends
LendingTreeās 2026 analysis places Subaruās accident rate at 23.2 per 1,000 drivers, the second-highest among the brands listed in the supplied summary. An earlier QuoteWizard/LendingTree analysis summarized by AutoBody News also placed Subaru among its higher overall incident-rate brands.
That consistency makes Subaru worth checking carefully in the dataābut it does not prove that Subaru vehicles are unsafe or that Subaru owners are uniformly poor drivers. Compare the exact model and year using IIHS safety ratings and NHTSA vehicle ratings, then check recalls and insurance quotes.
2. Volvo driver incident trends
The supplied LendingTree summary lists Volvo among the two makes with the lowest DUI rate, at 0.9 per 1,000 drivers, alongside Chrysler. It does not provide Volvoās overall incident rate, so we should not infer that a low DUI rate automatically means a low total incident rate.
Volvoās own safety information describes the brandās safety approach, but manufacturer claims and independent incident trends answer different questions. Check a specific Volvoās crash ratings, available driver-assistance equipment, and insurance costs before treating the badge as a shortcut to safety.
3. Honda driver incident trends
The Craft analysis reports 117 Honda ADAS-related incident reports in its NHTSA-related company table. That figure is a count of reports within a specific automation-related dataset, not Hondaās all-crash total, per-driver rate, or ranking for responsible drivers.
For a consumer comparison, look up the exact Honda model and year in NHTSAās ratings and recall tools and IIHS ratings. Hondaās official safety and driver-assistance information can help identify equipment, but equipment availability varies by model and trim.
4. Toyota driver incident trends
The Craft analysis lists 43 Toyota ADS/ADAS reports in its company table, combining its stated automation-related categories. As with every raw report total, that number is not normalized for fleet size, miles, or exposure and doesnāt establish Toyotaās all-vehicle crash rate.
For an apples-to-aples consumer decision, compare the specific Toyotaās crash-test results, standard safety features, recall history, and insurance quote. Toyotaās Safety Sense information describes its driver-assistance suite; read the ownerās manual to understand system limits rather than treating assistance as a substitute for attention.
5. Mazda driver incident trends
Mazdaās brand-level overall incident rate is not included in the supplied 2026 summary. LendingTree does report a DUI rate of 1.0 per 1,000 drivers for Mazda, placing it among several makes with relatively low recorded DUI rates in that dataset.
That component does not answer the whole question: the studyās overall rate includes additional incident categories. Check IIHS vehicle ratings, NHTSA safety ratings, and Mazdaās official i-Activsense safety information for model-specific evidence.
6. Hyundai driver incident trends
The Craft analysis lists 26 Hyundai-related ADS/ADAS reports in its automation-focused company table. That is neither a general Hyundai crash rate nor evidence that the brandās systems caused each event.
Hyundaiās SmartSense driver-assistance overview explains available technologies, while NHTSAās recall search and IIHS ratings provide independent checks. For a lease decision, compare the model year and trim youād actually getāsafety features can vary considerably across the lineup.
7. Kia driver incident trends
The Craft table lists 18 Kia ADS/ADAS reports. Its count combines a narrow category of automation-related reporting and is not a per-driver or per-mile brand ranking.
Kia publishes details about Drive Wise driver-assistance technologies, but feature names do not guarantee identical performance across models. Review the specific vehicleās crash ratings, recalls, and available insurance-loss information before drawing a brand-wide conclusion.
8. Ford driver incident trends
The Craft analysis lists 46 Ford reports across its stated ADS/ADAS categories. Since its table includes more than one system category and does not normalize report totals for fleet exposure, the count cannot be compared directly with a per-driver insurance incident rate.
Fordās official Co-Pilot360 information describes driver-assistance features. Check the relevant modelās ratings at NHTSA and IIHS; a large manufacturerās broad model range makes vehicle-by-vehicle checks especially important.
9. Chevrolet driver incident trends
The supplied summaries do not provide a Chevrolet overall incident rate or a Chevrolet-specific figure in the Craft table. That absence is not evidence of zero incidents or an especially low risk.
Chevroletās safety and driver-assistance information is a starting point for feature availability. For a fair comparison, look up the exact model, year, and trim in NHTSAās ratings and recall tools, then request an insurance quote using the actual vehicle identification details.
10. Nissan driver incident trends
The Craft analysis lists 16 Nissan ADAS reports in its automation-related company table. In LendingTreeās supplied 2026 summary, Nissanās DUI rate is 1.0 per 1,000 drivers, but an overall rate is not given.
Nissanās Safety Shield 360 overview explains available driver-assistance features. To judge a particular Nissan, pair that information with IIHS ratings, NHTSA crash-test data, and model-specific insurance quotes.
11. Volkswagen driver incident trends
Volkswagenās brand-wide overall incident figure is not in the supplied LendingTree summary. Its speeding rate is listed at 3.2 per 1,000 drivers, shared with Ram, Tesla, and Mercury in that analysis.
That is a single category, not a whole-brand safety verdict. Volkswagenās IQ.DRIVE information describes assistance technology; verify whatās standard on the model and trim youāre considering and review independent test results before relying on it.
12. BMW driver incident trends
BMW recorded the highest overall incident rate in LendingTreeās 2026 analysis, at 44.9 per 1,000 drivers. It also had the highest reported DUI rate, 4.8 per 1,000, while its accident rate was 22.9 per 1,000.
Those numbers indicate an elevated rate in the studyās sample, not that every BMW driver is irresponsible or every BMW is unsafe. LendingTreeās expert suggested high-performance models may influence the pattern, but that is an explanation to considerānot proof of cause. BMW buyers should compare model-specific safety results, powertrain and performance, insurance costs, and driver-assistance equipment. BMWās official driver-assistance information describes available features.
13. Mercedes-Benz driver incident trends
The supplied 2026 LendingTree summary does not give Mercedes-Benz an overall incident rate. The Craft automation-related table lists 23 Mercedes-Benz ADS/ADAS reports, which cannot be interpreted as a general driver incident rate.
Mercedes-Benz offers model-dependent driver assistance and safety equipment; check the manufacturerās safety and assistance information alongside independent IIHS ratings, NHTSA crash ratings, and your own insurance quote. Premium repair costs can affect insurance even when a driverās incident record is clean.
14. Dodge driver incident trends
The supplied summaries do not provide Dodgeās overall 2026 incident rate. An earlier LendingTree/QuoteWizard analysis reported Ramānot Dodgeāas one of its highest-rate makes. Ram and Dodge are distinct marques, so transferring one brandās rate to the other would be a data mistake.
For Dodge models, compare the exact vehicleās safety ratings, performance, crash history, and insurance quote. Manufacturer information is available through Dodgeās official site. A powerful vehicle may be enjoyable, but itās worth being honest about whether its performance suits your daily driving habits.
15. Tesla driver incident trends
LendingTree reported a Tesla overall incident rate of 42.8 per 1,000 drivers and an accident rate of 23.1 in its 2026 analysis. That places Tesla among the higher-rate makes in that sample.
A separate Craft analysis reports 2,732 Tesla ADS/ADAS incidents in its NHTSA-related table, the largest combined total in that table. But the analysis emphasizes that these totals are not adjusted for fleet size or exposure. It also notes that Teslaās Autopilot and Full Self-Driving features are classified as driver-assistance systems, not systems that make a retail vehicle fully autonomous.
That distinction matters: a crash report involving driver assistance is not automatically evidence that the vehicle was driving itself or that the manufacturer was legally at fault. Check NHTSAās automation and crash-investigation resources and Teslaās Autopilot information. Whatever the branding, the driver must remain attentive and responsible.
š Brand-by-Brand Incident Data Comparison
How to read the comparison table
The table below brings together the comparable figures supplied for the 2026 LendingTree study. Rates are per 1,000 drivers in that analysis.
| Brand or group | Overall incident rate | Accident rate | Additional reported detail |
|---|---|---|---|
| BMW | 44.9 | 22.9 | DUI rate: 4.8; highest overall and DUI rate |
| Ram | 44.7 | 23.9 | Highest accident rate; speeding rate: 3.2 |
| Tesla | 42.8 | 23.1 | Speeding rate: 3.2 |
| Subaru | Not specified | 23.2 | Second-highest accident rate in supplied summary |
| Chrysler | 25.5 | 12.9 | Lowest overall rate; DUI rate: 0.9 |
| Cadillac | 27.0 | Not specified | Second-lowest overall rate |
| Mercury | 27.9 | 12.7 | Lowest accident rate; speeding rate: 3.2 |
| Pontiac | Not specified | 13.3 | Low accident rate in supplied summary |
| Volvo | Not specified | Not specified | DUI rate: 0.9 |
| Buick | Not specified | Not specified | DUI rate: 1.7 |
| Infiniti | Not specified | Not specified | Highest speeding rate: 3.3 |
| Mazda | Not specified | Not specified | DUI rate: 1.0 |
| Nissan | Not specified | Not specified | DUI rate: 1.0 |
| Lexus | Not specified | Not specified | DUI rate: 1.0 |
| Volkswagen | Not specified | Not specified | Speeding rate: 3.2 |
āNot specifiedā does not mean a zero rate. It means the figure was not included in the supplied study summary. For the complete set and methodology, see LendingTreeās brand incident report.
Why rankings vary by incident measure
BMW leads the supplied overall-rate comparison, but Ram leads the accident-rate comparison. That is not a contradiction: overall incidents combine multiple categories, while accident rates isolate one. A brand can rank differently on DUI, speeding, citations, and accidents.
Hereās a quick text visualization of the four highest supplied accident rates:
Accidents per 1,000 drivers in LendingTreeās 2026 analysis
Ram 23.9 āāāā
Subaru 23.2 āāāā
Tesla 23.1 āāāā
BMW 22.9 āāāā
``
And the highest supplied overall rates:
```text
Overall incidents per 1,000 drivers
BMW 44.9 āāāā
Ram 44.7 āāāā
Tesla 42.8 āāāā
``
These bars make the sampleās order easier to scan, **not** the actual probability that youāll have an incident. For another perspective, the older [QuoteWizard/LendingTree analysis summarized by AutoBody News](https://www.autobodynews.com/news/ram-tesla-subaru-have-worst-drivers-bmw-drivers-have-highest-dui-rates) ranked Ram highest overall in its study period. Different time windows and datasets can reasonably change the order.
## š¦ Which Brands Show Lower-Risk Driving Patterns?
āLower-riskā needs a qualifier. In LendingTreeās supplied 2026 figures, Chrysler has the lowest **overall** rate among the included brands, while Mercury has the lowest **accident** rate. Volvo and Chrysler share the lowest listed **DUI** rate. Those are three different findings.
### Brands associated with fewer reported incidents
The supplied study summary identifies:
- **Chrysler:** lowest overall incident rate at **25.5 per 1,000 drivers**.
- **Cadillac:** second-lowest overall at **27.0**.
- **Mercury:** third-lowest overall at **27.9**, and lowest accident rate at **12.7**.
- **Chrysler and Volvo:** lowest reported DUI rate, each at **0.9**.
- **Pontiac:** accident rate of **13.3**, though its overall rate is not supplied.
These results are useful for understanding the study, but several of the makes are discontinued or have smaller, older vehicle populations. That can affect who appears in a modern insurance-inquiry sample. **Donāt lease an older or discontinued model based on a brand-rate headline alone.** Check parts support, recalls, safety equipment, and the specific vehicleās condition.
### Brands associated with higher-risk incident patterns
In LendingTreeās 2026 dataset, **BMW, Ram, and Tesla** had the three highest overall incident rates among the 30 analyzed makes. Ram, Subaru, Tesla, and BMW were the four makes with the highest supplied accident rates.
That gives prospective shoppers a reason to look more closely at model, performance, driver profile, and insuranceānot a reason to presume every owner is a risk. In the earlier analysis summarized by AutoBody News, Ram ranked first overall and Tesla second, reinforcing that higher-rate makes can recur across studies while the exact ranking changes.
### Why āresponsibleā doesnāt mean ācrash-proofā
A low incident rate does not guarantee a safe outcome in every collision. Crashworthiness depends on the vehicleās structure, restraints, crash type, and occupantsā circumstances. Conversely, a well-rated vehicle can still be involved in a collision because another driver ran a light or conditions turned hazardous.
Use rankings as **one filter, not the final verdict**:
1. Compare incident data using the same study and measure.
2. Check crash-test results for the exact model year.
3. Review open recalls and completed repairs.
4. Get insurance quotes for the vehicle you intend to lease.
5. Consider whether the vehicle fits your driving, parking, and passenger needs.
## š”ļø How Vehicle Safety Features Affect Incident Outcomes
Safety technology can help prevent some crashes or reduce their severity. It does not turn a driver into a passenger. The [NHTSA explains](https://www.nhtsa.gov/vehicle-safety/driver-assistance-technologies) that driver-assistance features support driving tasks; drivers remain responsible for operating the vehicle.
### Automatic emergency braking and forward collision warning
**Forward collision warning** can alert a driver to a possible frontal collision. **Automatic emergency braking (AEB)** may apply braking when a collision risk is detected, depending on the system and conditions. NHTSA provides an overview of these [driver-assistance technologies](https://www.nhtsa.gov/vehicle-safety/driver-assistance-technologies), and IIHS evaluates features such as [front crash prevention](https://www.ihs.org/ratings/about-our-tests).
Potential benefits:
- Gives a driver another warning when attention slips.
- May help reduce speed before a collision.
- Can help address some common rear-end crash scenarios.
Limits to respect:
- Systems may not detect every person, object, lane, or road condition.
- Visibility, weather, lighting, speed, and sensor condition can matter.
- A warning or braking intervention does not excuse tailgating or distraction.
### Lane-keeping assistance and blind-spot monitoring
**Lane-departure warning** alerts when the vehicle drifts from a lane. **Lane-keeping assistance** may provide steering input to help keep the vehicle within lane markings. **Blind-spot monitoring** can warn about vehicles beside or approaching the car.
These tools are useful, especially on long drives, but they have boundaries. Lane markings may be unclear; blind-spot sensors may not cover every situation; and driver-assistance steering is not the same as hands-free driving. Check the ownerās manual and test the controls before depending on a feature.
### Driver-assistance systems: benefits and limitations
Automakers use different names and packages for assistance features, and equipment varies by trim and model year. A practical pre-lease checklist:
- ā
Confirm which features are **standard**, optional, or unavailable on your exact trim.
- ā
Ask whether the system requires driver monitoring or hands on the wheel.
- ā
Read the vehicle manual for limitations and warning behavior.
- ā
Check whether sensors or cameras need calibration after repairs.
- ā Donāt assume a marketing name means the car can drive itself.
- ā Donāt treat adaptive cruise control or lane-centering as permission to text.
If youāre considering an EV with advanced assistance, compare it alongside other [electric vehicle lease options](https://www.carleases.org/category/electric-vehicle-leases/). The propulsion type does not change the driverās responsibility.
## š§ Brand, Model, or Driver: What Matters Most?
For a shopper, the most useful answer is usually not āWhich logo has the best reputation?ā Itās **āWhich exact vehicle fits my needs, protects people well, and can I insure and lease on sensible terms?ā**
### Why one model can differ from its brand average
A brand can sell compact cars, family SUVs, performance models, pickups, and electric vehicles. They have different sizes, power, visibility, equipment, repair costs, and typical uses. A brand-level average smooths all of that into one number.
For each candidate, compare:
| Check | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Model year and trim | Safety equipment and crash structures can change across versions. |
| IIHS and NHTSA ratings | Independent tests help assess crash avoidance and crash protection. |
| Recall status | A recall may involve a safety defect that needs repair. |
| Insurance quote | Repair costs, theft risk, and claim history can affect premiums. |
| Driver-assistance equipment | Availability and operation differ by model and trim. |
| Real-world fit | Visibility, size, parking, and daily use affect how comfortable you are driving it. |
### Vehicle size, performance, and visibility
A vehicleās power and size may affect how it feels to drive and how it is used, but neither is a standalone measure of responsibility. A quick-accelerating car can tempt some drivers to push harder; a large vehicle can require more room and careful visibility checks. Those are practical considerations, not judgments about every owner.
We like to sit in the actual trim, check sightlines, and drive it on the kinds of roads we use most. A vehicle that feels composed and easy to place in a parking garage may suit your routine better than one that wins a spec-sheet sprint. For lease shoppers, the [Best Lease Terms](https://www.carleases.org/category/best-lease-terms/) category is a useful companion to model research.
### How driving habits shape crash risk
The [NHTSA identifies](https://www.nhtsa.gov/risky-driving) risky driving behaviors such as speeding and impaired driving as major safety concerns. Distraction is another hazard: [NHTSAās distracted-driving guidance](https://www.nhtsa.gov/risky-driving/distracted-driving) recommends putting the phone away and keeping attention on the road.
Weāve all seen the familiar scene: traffic slows, one driver looks down, and suddenly the carefully maintained following distance disappears. A few habits are simple and powerful:
- Leave enough space to stop smoothly.
- Set navigation and music before moving.
- Keep your phone out of reach or use driving mode.
- Never drive impaired or ride with an impaired driver.
- Slow down for weather, work zones, and limited visibility.
- Take a break when fatigue starts bargaining with you.
## ā
How to Choose a Safer Car and Drive More Responsibly
Hereās a straightforward process that keeps brand headlines in perspective and focuses on the vehicle youāll actually drive.
### Check crash-test ratings and recalls
**Step 1: Identify the exact model year and trim.** āA Hondaā or āa BMWā is too broad; safety equipment and test results can vary.
**Step 2: Check independent crash ratings.** Search the model on [NHTSAās vehicle ratings page](https://www.nhtsa.gov/ratings) and [IIHSās ratings page](https://www.ihs.org/ratings).
**Step 3: Search for recalls by VIN or model.** Use [NHTSAās recall lookup](https://www.nhtsa.gov/recalls). Ask the dealer whether any open recalls will be completed before delivery.
**Step 4: Confirm the safety equipment on the lease vehicle.** Donāt rely on a generic brochure if the feature is trim-dependent.
### Compare insurance loss and claim data
**Step 5: Get insurance quotes before signing.** The same brand can have very different insurance costs across models. Ask insurers to quote the exact year, trim, coverage, deductible, location, and driver details.
**Step 6: Compare insurers, not just vehicle badges.** Insurers weigh claims and driver factors differently. LendingTree expert Rob Bhatt recommends shopping around; its report also notes that an individual driving violation can affect a driverās premium independently of a brandās broader reputation.
**Step 7: Ask about coverage for your circumstances.** Consider liability limits, collision and comprehensive coverage, uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage, and any lease requirements. For help sorting financing and insurance-adjacent questions, see [Auto Financing Options](https://www.carleases.org/category/auto-financing-options/).
### Practical habits that reduce incident risk
**Step 8: Treat assistance features as backup.** Learn the limits before using adaptive cruise, lane-centering, or emergency braking features.
**Step 9: Protect your record.** Avoid speeding, distraction, and impaired driving. LendingTreeās expert puts it plainly: āJust avoiding these three things can help you avoid accidents and other incidents.ā
**Step 10: Review telematics and privacy choices.** Before enrolling in an insurer or manufacturer driving-data program, read what is collected, how it is shared, whether it affects a discount, and how to opt out. The video perspective referenced [earlier](#featured-video) highlights why connected-car data deserves attention as well as convenience.
**Step 11: Compare the full lease, not only the monthly payment.** Review mileage allowance, wear-and-use rules, insurance requirements, and end-of-lease terms. Our guides to [Car Lease Basics](https://www.carleases.org/category/car-lease-basics/) and [Best Lease Terms](https://www.carleases.org/category/best-lease-terms/) can help you compare the details.
## ā Frequently Asked Questions
### Which car brand has the most responsible drivers?
There is no definitive, universal winner because āresponsibleā can mean fewer accidents, citations, DUIs, or speeding recordsāand different datasets include different drivers. In LendingTreeās 2026 study, Chrysler had the lowest overall incident rate among the 30 makes analyzed, at **25.5 per 1,000 drivers**. That is a study-specific result, not proof that every Chrysler driver is responsible or that the brand is safest in every crash scenario.
### Which car brands have the most accidents per driver?
In LendingTreeās 2026 analysis, the highest supplied accident rates were **Ram (23.9), Subaru (23.2), Tesla (23.1), and BMW (22.9) per 1,000 drivers**. These figures reflect that reportās insurance-inquiry sample and are not per-mile crash rates. They also do not establish that every recorded accident was caused by the driver of that make.
### Are luxury-car drivers involved in more crashes?
The 2026 analysis reported BMW at the highest overall incident rate and highest accident rate among the figures supplied, but that does not mean luxury vehicles as a class necessarily have more crashes. Performance, mileage, owner demographics, vehicle mix, and sample composition may contribute. Luxury-car insurance can also be affected by **repair and replacement costs**, separate from incident frequency. Compare the exact model and get personalized insurance quotes.
### Are popular car brands safer because they have more data?
More data can make a studyās estimates more stable, but popularity does not make a car safer. A high-volume brand may generate more raw crash reports simply because more vehicles are on the road. That is why **rates and exposure-adjusted comparisons matter**, and why crash-test ratings should be considered separately from incident counts.
### Do safety features make drivers more responsible?
No. Features such as automatic emergency braking, lane-departure warning, and blind-spot monitoring can assist with certain driving tasks, but they donāt change a driverās legal or practical responsibility. Learn the systemās limits, stay attentive, and follow the ownerās manual and [NHTSAās driver-assistance guidance](https://www.nhtsa.gov/vehicle-safety/driver-assistance-technologies).
### Can driver incident rankings predict my insurance costs?
Not reliably. Insurers typically assess the **specific vehicle and driver**, location, coverage, claims history, and other rating factors. A brand-level incident ranking is not an individual quote. Compare insurance costs for the exact model and your own circumstances before committing to a lease.
### Where can I find reliable car-crash and vehicle-safety data?
Start with [NHTSA crash-test ratings](https://www.nhtsa.gov/ratings), [NHTSA recall searches](https://www.nhtsa.gov/recalls), and [IIHS safety ratings](https://www.ihs.org/ratings). For driver incident comparisons, read the full [LendingTree brand incident report](https://www.lendingtree.com/insurance/brand-incidents-study/) and review its definitions, sample, time period, and denominator. For automated-driving reports, consult [NHTSAās automated vehicle safety information](https://www.nhtsa.gov/vehicle-safety/automated-vehicles-safety) and distinguish raw report totals from normalized rates.
### Should you compare car insurance quotes before leasing a car after a speeding ticket?
**Yes.** A speeding ticket can affect your insurance premium, and insurers may treat the same violation differently. Get quotes using the exact vehicle and coverage youāll need before you sign the lease. Avoid assuming that a brand with a lower average incident rate will offset a violation on your personal record.
### How do driver incident rates influence car lease prices?
Brand incident rates generally do **not** directly determine a leaseās advertised payment. Lease terms depend on factors such as vehicle price, residual value, money factor, term, mileage allowance, taxes, fees, and your qualifications. Incident and claim trends may influence insurance costs or, over time, vehicle pricing and residual assumptions, but you should compare the actual lease worksheet and insurance quote rather than treating a brand ranking as a payment forecast. See [Car Lease Basics](https://www.carleases.org/category/car-lease-basics/) for lease-term details.
### Which car brands are best for safe driving and lease offers?
There is no single brand that guarantees both excellent safety and the best lease offer. Shortlist specific models with strong [IIHS](https://www.ihs.org/ratings) and [NHTSA](https://www.nhtsa.gov/ratings) results, confirm the safety equipment, then compare current lease terms and insurance quotes. A reliable compact or midsize model may make more sense than a higher-powered vehicle if your priority is predictable commuting and lower ownership costs.
### Can choosing a responsible car brand lower my insurance premiums?
It might contribute indirectly, but **your individual quote depends on much more than brand reputation**. Model repair costs, safety equipment, theft risk, location, driver history, coverage, and insurer rules all matter. Request multiple quotes for the same vehicle and coverage so the comparison is fair.
### Which car brands have the fewest driver incidents per mile?
The supplied LendingTree figures are **per 1,000 drivers**, not per mile, so they cannot identify a most responsible brand by mileage-adjusted incident rate. A per-mile ranking requires reliable vehicle-miles-traveled data linked to brand and incident records. Donāt convert a per-driver result into a per-mile conclusion.
### What are the safest car brands based on accident and insurance data?
āSafestā combines several questions: crash prevention, crash protection, injury outcomes, and claim costs. LendingTreeās incident study measures recorded driver incidents in an insurance-inquiry dataset; IIHS and NHTSA assess vehicle safety through their own testing and ratings. For a meaningful answer, compare **the specific model and year**, not just the brand, and review both independent safety results and insurance quotes.
### Which car brands have the lowest rates of at-fault crashes?
The supplied LendingTree summary provides accident rates, but it does not give a complete brand-by-brand ranking of **at-fault** crashes. Its accident figures should not be presented as fault-adjusted rates unless the source explicitly defines them that way. Check the methodology of any study making an at-fault claim.
### How do driver incident rates compare across car brands?
In the supplied 2026 LendingTree results, overall rates ranged from **25.5 per 1,000 drivers for Chrysler** to **44.9 for BMW** among the analyzed makes. Accident rates differed: Mercury had the lowest supplied figure at **12.7**, while Ram had the highest at **23.9**. The rankings change because overall incident rates combine several categories while accident rates isolate crashes.
### Which reliable car brands are also affordable to lease?
Lease affordability is specific to the model, market, lease term, and your qualifications; it cannot be determined from incident data alone. Compare models with strong reliability and safety evidence, then review lease terms, mileage limits, insurance costs, and maintenance coverage. Check our [Best Lease Terms](https://www.carleases.org/category/best-lease-terms/) and [Auto Financing Options](https://www.carleases.org/category/auto-financing-options/) resources.
### Are leased cars from safer brands cheaper to insure?
Not automatically. A vehicle with strong crash ratings may have costly parts or repairs, while a less expensive model may have different theft or claims patterns. Insurers price the **specific vehicle and policy**, not a simple āsafe brandā label. Get quotes before signing and compare the same coverage across insurers.
### What car brands offer the best lease deals and lowest accident rates?
There is no permanent brand-level winner: lease offers change, and the studyās accident rates do not measure lease value. Compare current offers on models with strong crash ratings, then calculate the complete lease obligation and obtain an insurance quote. A lower monthly payment is not necessarily the best deal if mileage limits, fees, or insurance costs are unfavorable.
### Can a brandās driving-data practices affect my insurance?
Possibly, if you enroll in a telematics program or authorize data sharing. Policies differ, so read the vehicle privacy notice and insurer agreement to see what data is collected, how it is used, and whether it can affect rates. The privacy concerns summarized in the [featured-video discussion](#featured-video) are a reminder to check the terms rather than assume all connected-car data is handled the same way.





